Blog asks #WhatsyourlegacyDave ? and how would he be remembered, for a broken promise?

In a new blog for HACAN, a long standing member, Jenine Langrish, writes about the likely legacy of David Cameron – and the main thing for which he would go down in history.  And not in a good way. She asks how history will remember the three key party leaders in recent times: Tony Blair, Nick Clegg, and David Cameron.  Tony Blair led Labour to their biggest ever majority, 3 election victories, and much else besides – but if you ask the man in the street – he’s remembered for just one thing: his misguided decision to support George Bush’s invasion of Iraq.  Nick Clegg secured enough votes to hold the balance of power following 2010’s election, giving his party real power. But if you ask the man in the street, Clegg is remembered for breaking his promise on student tuition fees. And David Cameron has many key achievements on the economy and keeping his party’s divisions on Europe under control. But his highest profile promise is of course ‘No ifs, no buts, no third runway’.  His party said no runways at Gatwick or Stansted either. As he appears to stand on the brink of an about turn on Heathrow he would do well to reflect on the lessons of Tony Blair and Nick Clegg.  Dave – how do you want to be remembered?  #WhatsyourlegacyDave?
.

Dave – what’s your legacy?

Guest blog from Jenine Langrish – for HACAN

#WhatsyourlegacyDave ?

Three parties, three leaders: Tony Blair; Nick Clegg; and David Cameron.  How will history remember them?

Tony Blair united the Labour party and led them to their biggest ever majority and three consecutive election victories.  His government oversaw the introduction of a national minimum wage; freedom of information; devolution; and the signing of the Good Friday agreement.

And yet…if you ask the man in the street, he’s remembered for just one thing: his misguided decision to support George Bush’s invasion of Iraq, justified by the claim that Saddam Hussein had ‘weapons of mass destruction’.

That single policy decision has led to mass vilification in the media and ensures that he will forever be remembered as “Tony B-liar”.

Under Nick Clegg’s leadership the Lib Dems soared in popularity and surprised everyone by securing enough votes to hold the balance of power following 2010’s election.  For the first time since the days of Asquith and Lloyd George, the political party in the centre of politics held real power.  They can claim credit for a number of policies in the coalition government, notably raising the tax threshold to take over 3 million low earners out of the income tax system; introducing the pupil premium; and creating the Green Investment Bank.

And yet…once again, if you ask the man in the street, Clegg is remembered for just one thing: breaking his promise on student tuition fees.

That single concession in the coalition agreement discussions led to highly personal attacks in the media and to his party’s vote being decimated in the last election.

Which brings me to David Cameron.  He can claim credit for having overseen the recovery from the financial crisis; bringing the deficit under control; and generally keeping his party’s divisions on Europe under control.

But how will he be remembered in ten years time?  The lesson from Tony Blair and Nick Clegg is that the public have little tolerance if they believe politicians have lied or broken high profile promises.  Part of the reason for Jeremy Corbyn’s surprise ascendancy appears to be that Labour’s grass roots supporters saw him as an honest man who’d do what he said he would.

David Cameron’s highest profile promise is of course ‘No ifs, no buts, no third runway’.  As he appears to stand on the brink of an about turn on Heathrow he would do well to reflect on the lessons of Tony Blair and Nick Clegg.

Dave – how do you want to be remembered?  Do you want to be judged on your policies or simply remembered as the latest in a line of political leaders who broke their promises.  The choice is yours.

#WhatsyourlegacyDave?

http://hacan.org.uk/blog/?p=434

.

.

As a reminder of what Cameron and the Conservative party said in May 2010:

No ifs No buts

In their document produced in May 2010, with the title “Freedom, Fairness, Responsibility” on Page 16 it states:

• We will cancel the third runway at Heathrow.

• We will refuse permission for additional runways at Gatwick and Stansted
https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/78977/coalition_programme_for_government.pdf


 

This was reported in the media:

The new government said it would also refuse any additional runways at Gatwick and Stansted airports.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/london/8678282.stm

.

The Cameron/Clegg government confirmed yesterday evening that it will not only scrap the third runway at Heathrow, but also refuse additional runways at Gatwick and Stansted.
http://www.greenpeace.org.uk/blog/climate/third-runway-we-won-20100513

.

The UK government confirmed last month that it would not allow new runways at Heathrow, Gatwick and Stansted, causing frustration in the aviation industry.
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/acbaf13c-74f6-11df-aed7-00144feabdc0.html#axzz3oibV9tfY

.

Heathrow’s third runway will be scrapped, no new ones will be built at Stansted or Gatwick,
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/journalists/geoffrey-lean/7726032/David-Camerons-coalition-is-off-to-a-green-start.html

.

.

.