Belfast schools hit by City airport’s noise proposals
Belfast City airport has submitted proposals that would replace an existing passenger cap with one controlling noise. This will increase the amount of total noise experienced by those near flight paths. Belfast City Airport Watch (BCAW) believes this would mean that 21 schools would potentially be subjected to aircraft noise at a level above that recommended by the WHO, and 9 would would potentially experience aircraft noise at a level which the UK government regards as serious. Up to 46,000 people in Belfast and north Down would also be affected at levels well above those recommended by WHO. BCAW says “Under these proposals, the City Airport could become one of the noisiest in the UK, in terms of its effect on schools and the local population. There is a robust body of research which shows that high levels of aircraft noise impact negatively on children’s education and on people’s health.” The Department of the Environment is currently carrying out a public consultation into the airport proposals.
Schools hit by airport’s noise proposals
Children’s education will suffer say teaching union and residents
25th May 2012 (Belfast City Airport Watch)
Cillian Burns (13) from Ballynafeigh in south Belfast went to a primary school affected by aircraft noise.
A teaching union has joined local residents in expressing alarm at proposals submitted by George Best Belfast City Airport which would significantly raise permissible noise levels at 21 schools.
A total of 21 schools – 19 in Belfast and two in Holywood – have been identified as schools which would be impacted in an application which the airport has made to the Department of the Environment to increase the permitted noise thresholds in its planning agreement.
The schools include two top grammar schools, a private prep school, eleven primary schools, an infants’ school and four nursery schools. Four of the primary schools also have nursery classes attached.
Under the proposals, all 21 schools would potentially be subjected to aircraft noise at a level above that recommended by the World Health Organisation (WHO). Nine schools would potentially experience aircraft noise at a level which the UK government regards as serious.
Up to 46,000 people in Belfast and north Down would also be affected at levels well above those recommended by WHO, according to the airport’s submission.
Dr Liz Fawcett, Chair of the Belfast City Airport Watch (BCAW) Steering Group said:
“The airport is proposing a massive increase in permissible noise levels which would undoubtedly have a really negative impact on the education of thousands of children, and on the health and quality of life of tens of thousands of residents.
“Under these proposals, the City Airport could become one of the noisiest in the UK, in terms of its effect on schools and the local population.
“There is a robust body of research which shows that high levels of aircraft noise impact negatively on children’s education and on people’s health.
“We hope the Environment Minister will reject the airport’s application which we regard as utterly unacceptable.”
The teaching union, the Association of Teachers and Lecturers (ATL), has joined BCAW in expressing concern about the proposals.
Mark Langhammer, Northern Ireland Director of the ATL, said:
“We are very concerned at the potential impact of these proposals, given the evidence which exists on the detrimental effect on children’s education of aircraft noise.
“We would not want to see any drive for airport expansion take place at the expense of children’s education.
“Many of the schools identified by the airport are in areas which suffer from social deprivation.
“Their pupils are already at an educational disadvantage due to their backgrounds – they don’t need the further handicap of excessive aircraft noise.”
A comprehensive review of research on the impact of aircraft noise on children’s learning, carried out by the Civil Aviation Authority in 2010, concluded:
“..there is evidence to suggest that chronic aircraft noise has a deleterious effect on memory, sustained attention, reading comprehension and reading ability”.
In a survey of local schools in Belfast and north Down carried out by BCAW in 2008, 12 schools reported that aircraft noise adversely affected pupils’ concentration.
One child who has experienced the problems first hand is 13-year old Cillian Burns from Ballynafeigh in south Belfast.
He previously attended a primary school which is on the airport’s list of potentially affected schools and says teaching at the school was already disrupted by aircraft noise.
“At my previous school, when a loud plane went over, the teacher had to stop talking because they couldn’t be heard,” he said. “And that got really distracting at times.
“The noise can also be annoying when I’m trying to do my homework. I certainly wouldn’t want the level of noise to get any worse.”
The Department of the Environment is currently carrying out a public consultation into the airport’s proposals. It has also said it intends to hold a formal Examination in Public into the application.
Editor’s notes:
- Belfast City AirportWatch comprises 20 residents’ and community groups across affected areas within east and south Belfast, and north Down. For more information on the campaign, visit: www.belfastcityairportwatch.co.uk
- The airport’s proposals can be viewed here: http://apps2.planningni.gov.uk/PlanningBCA/EnvInfo.aspx The document which lists the schools and the population numbers which would be affected by the proposals is at: http://apps2.planningni.gov.uk/PlanningBCA/DOCS/Annex%20B%20-%20NOISE%20CONTROL%20CONTOUR%20REPORT.pdf Our figures are taken from Tables C2 and C4 in this latter document. Please note that the document incorrectly states that Priory Integrated College is in the BT9 postal code area. It is in Holywood (BT18).
- The government’s guidance on aircraft noise levels is available at: http://www.caa.co.uk/default.aspx?catid=68&pagetype=70&gid=69&faqid=27 It states that ‘significant community annoyance’ occurs at 57 LAeq or over, averaged over 16 hours.
- The World Health Organisation (WHO) recommends that aircraft noise levels should not exceed 50 LAeq, averaged over 16 hours. The specific WHO guidance on noise levels is available at: http://www.who.int/docstore/peh/noise/Comnoise-4.pdf (section 4.3.1). The full report Guidelines for Community Noise is available at:http://www.who.int/docstore/peh/noise/guidelines2.html
- The Civil Aviation Authority research review, cited in this news release, is available at: http://www.caa.co.uk/docs/33/ERCD200908.pdf
- The Airport’s Planning Agreement is an agreement between the Department of the Environment and the Airport. The current Agreement came into force on 14th October 2008.
www.belfastcityairportwatch.co.uk
Teachers’ concern at airport plans
Press Association 25.5.2012
- George Best Belfast City Airport plans to implement noise control measures
More than 20 schools will suffer from increased noise levels because of proposed changes at George Best Belfast City Airport, a residents’ campaign group has claimed.
The airport has put forward noise control measures but lobby group Belfast City Airport Watch said 21 schools in Belfast and Holywood, Co Down, would be affected by the possible new limits.
The proposal by George Best Belfast City Airport would replace an existing passenger cap with one controlling noise.
Teaching union the Association of Teachers and Lecturers (ATL) expressed concern.
Northern Ireland director Mark Langhammer said: “We are very concerned at the potential impact of these proposals, given the evidence which exists on the detrimental effect on children’s education of aircraft noise. We would not want to see any drive for airport expansion take place at the expense of children’s education.
“Many of the schools identified by the airport are in areas which suffer from social deprivation. Their pupils are already at an educational disadvantage due to their backgrounds – they don’t need the further handicap of excessive aircraft noise.”
Airport officials are seeking to modify a planning agreement between the city hub and the Department of Environment ruling that operators using the airport may not sell more than two million scheduled flight seats in any 12-month period. Instead, the airport is proposing to remove the “seats for sale” restriction and put in its place noise control measures.
A total of 21 schools are affected by proposed increases in permissible noise levels, according to the residents’ group, including two top grammar schools, a private prep school, 11 primary schools, an infant’s school and four nurseries.
Katy Best, director of business development at George Best Belfast City Airport, said: “We are extremely concerned that once again Belfast City Airport Watch is attempting to use children to try and convey a point.
“The airport has never received a complaint of any nature from any schools nor education boards concerning noise. We have a very close working relationship with schools and teachers in the area and many of our staff have children enrolled in local schools.”
http://uk.news.yahoo.com/teachers-concern-airport-plans-230601244.html